A flag of pride to some, a sign of racism to others

School prohibits the wearing or displaying Confederate flag on campus


Benjamin Prengler

The Civil War ended 150 years ago, but the Confederate flag is still a hot topic.

By Savannah Whitmer

150 years after the Civil War ended and the Union was brought back together, some people in the South still acknowledge the Confederacy by flying rebel flags. Multiple students on campus can be seen with Confederate merchandise, including flags on cars, clothes, or other visible accessories, despite the negative undertones many people have surrounding the Confederacy.

Junior Josh Shewmake is aware of the prejudice that is often associated with the Confederate flag. He has the flag on the headliner of his truck and flies it often.

It’s more [representative of] pride in being yourself, and being independent.”

— Josh Shewmake, junior

“Nowadays, it means more of like, southern pride,” Shewmake said. “It’s not meant to come across as offensive, like some people take it. It’s more [representative of] pride in being yourself, and being independent.”

While most people associate the Confederate flag with slavery, sophomore Davis DeShields, who owns a wallet and clothes with the flag, believes it has nothing to do with slavery.

“[Confederate soldiers] actually fought on the southern side [with slaves],” DeShields said. “If people take offense to it, they just need to understand that it doesn’t have anything to do with slavery. It’s showing that the slaves actually fought for the southern side, which shows that they helped, and they actually had that flag whenever they were doing it.”

Deshield’s perception isn’t uncommon, but in fact, fewer than one percent of the soldiers that fought for for the South during the Civil War were freedmen or slaves. All were barred from enlisting until 1865, but an estimated 180,000 freedmen and slaves fought for the Union, which amounts to about 10 percent of the Union army.

The reason that blacks fought for the South is because the choice was to fight or get shot.”

— Brian Erskine, history teacher

“The reason that blacks fought for the South is because the choice was to fight or get shot,” AP U.S. History teacher Brian Erskine said. “Slave owners would send their slaves to fight or to do the awful work, like carrying the flag, which is like a big target. So that wasn’t fair to them.”

But people who support wearing the flag say that it implies living in the South more than it implies the negative aspects associated with the Confederacy and the Civil War. In addition to wearing the flag to school, junior Cody Cummings has the rebel flag on his ceiling, his truck, and his wallet.

“It’s just pride in my heritage,” Cummings said. “I’m supporting the southern half of America. It’s just pride in my heritage, which is southern Texas, and that’s pretty much all there is to it.”

Regardless of any harmless intentions, some argue that the Confederate flag and the principles that are associated with it should not be glorified.

“The Civil War accomplished two things,” Erskine said. “It killed a lot of people, and it created about 80 years worth of racism. So some people will say that they have a claim to their heritage, or they have some kind of right to display it, as a way to remember. Well, what are you remembering?…I suspect that most people who display the Confederate flag are not educated about what they’re really doing.”

Recently, administrators have noticed the rebel flag on clothing, and have restricted students from wearing it, asking them to change clothes if it is visible.

“I’ve been told multiple times that I’m no longer allowed to wear [the flag], and I still do,” Shewmake said. “In the student code of conduct, there is nothing that says I’m not allowed to, but the principals are on me about wearing it… I think you should be able to wear whatever you want.”

Administrators cite the Student Handbook’s list of prohibited clothing, which includes anything depicting sex, violence, drugs, tobacco, alcohol, death, gang or hate slogans or pictures.

“We’re actually considering that part of the ‘hate slogan,’ which is under number one in prohibited clothing,” associate principal Teresa Dodson said. “And if you really go out and do enough research on the Confederate flag, what you’ll see is that there’s been enough controversy around that particularly in schools where it is viewed that way. So we’ve had to say, yes, at Lovejoy High School, it’s a prohibited item.”

Other students on campus, both black and white, recognize the controversy surrounding the rebel flag.

“The people who waved Confederate flags around in the Civil War are the ones who wanted slavery around,” junior Ben Ominara said. “That’s offensive, ignorant, and narrow-minded.”

Administrators and other people on campus argue that people should not wear Confederate flags to school because it is an item that has, in the minds of many, an inextricable connection to racism.

“What a lot of guys will tell you is that it’s like a symbol of rebellion, or independence, or ‘fighting the man,’” Erskine said. “What they don’t realize is, people who were a part of the Confederacy were committing treason. So even if we’re not talking about slavery, we’re not talking about black and white relations and civil rights, what we’re talking about is a group of people who committed treason against the Constitution.”

Those who consider the flag to be “a southern roots thing” insist that publicly flying the flag is not meant to condone the values that Confederates stood for during the Civil War.

“Just because I fly the rebel flag doesn’t mean that I’m racist,” Cummings said. “Just because I’m proud of where I’m from, and who I am doesn’t mean that I’m racist, doesn’t mean that I’m prejudiced or anything. It’s just pride. It’s just part of who I am.”